Texas · Insights
Handing Over the Pen: How Texas Districts Are Winning Bonds After the Ballot Changed
Since House Bill 3 and Senate Bill 30 rewrote the Texas school bond ballot, passage rates have slipped — but the districts that hand the package to a citizen committee keep winning.
For decades a Texas school bond followed a familiar script. The administration assessed its buildings, the financial advisor sized the debt, the board called the election, and the district spent eight weeks explaining the package at town halls. From 2004 through 2019, about three of every four bond propositions in Texas passed.
In 2019 the Legislature changed the script. House Bill 3 requires every school bond proposition to carry the sentence “THIS IS A PROPERTY TAX INCREASE”, even when the district's tax rate will not move. Senate Bill 30 requires stadiums, natatoriums, performing arts centers and similar projects to stand alone as separate propositions. Since 2020 the statewide pass rate has fallen to 63 percent. In 2022 it was 53.
The averages hide the real story, which is the calendar. Before 2020, May and November bond elections passed at nearly the same rate. Since then, May propositions have passed 72 percent of the time and November propositions 50 percent. In Bexar County the split is starker: 12 of 13 May propositions have passed since 2020, and 10 of 30 in November. A November electorate is three to four times larger, and most of those voters meet the bond for the first time on the ballot, under a sentence written to make them hesitate.
That is the problem a district has to solve. A voter who first learns of a bond from the ballot reads a tax warning. A voter who has already heard about it from a neighbor reads a decision their community made. No mailer closes that gap, and the law limits who may try.
The district cannot ask for a yes
Texas Election Code 255.003 bars school officials and employees from spending public funds to advocate for a measure. A district may state the facts. It may not ask for a vote. The only people who can campaign are citizens, on their own time and with their own money. A superintendent who builds a package behind closed doors and then looks for volunteers to sell it is recruiting advocates for a plan they had no part in. Few show up.
A citizen steering committee reverses the order. Residents study the facility assessment, tour the buildings, hear the debt capacity from the financial advisor, and decide what goes in the package. By the time the board calls the election, forty or sixty people can explain every line of it, and they are free to say so in public.
What the comeback districts did
Medina Valley ISD lost a $383 million proposition in May 2022 with 41 percent of the vote. It convened a community committee of more than thirty members, published a summary after every meeting, removed athletics and returned with $376 million for schools and safety. In May 2023 it passed with 63 percent, and two more propositions passed a year later. Joshua ISD lost in May 2022 and again in November 2023. Its citizen committee then split the plan into four specific propositions and promised an oversight committee. All four passed in May 2024. Argyle ISD lost two propositions in May 2024, let a parent-led committee cut $89 million, and won both a year later.
These districts changed more than their process. They cut their packages, set athletics apart and chose May. Statewide since 2020, districts returning after a full defeat have won at least one proposition 68 percent of the time in May and 37 percent in November. A committee is how the other changes get made, and made in public. It does not replace them. Angleton and Crosby formed committees too, went to November ballots, and lost by wide margins.
Advice for superintendents
The hard part is the tension between the people who know the buildings and the people who pay for them. Three practices manage it.
- Set the boundary, then give up the pen. Give the committee a firm debt ceiling and a deadline, both in writing. Inside those limits the choices are theirs.
- Let staff present needs, not a package. The facility assessment is the shared set of facts. When citizens challenge a cost, bring the engineer, not a defense.
- Commit the board in advance. The board adopts the recommendation or explains any change publicly, with the committee's chairs in the room.
Answering the ballot sentence
The tax-increase sentence cannot be removed, so it has to be answered before election day. In many Texas communities the answer is concrete. The school homestead exemption is now $140,000, and $200,000 for homeowners 65 or older. A family in a home valued below the exemption pays no school property tax at any rate, and a bond cannot raise the school taxes on a senior's homestead. Those facts persuade when a neighbor shows them with the voter's own address in a tax calculator. They do not persuade from a district flyer read once.
A district that wants its community to vote for a bond should let its community write it.